Fat Dan’s Deli
Best Restaurant 2018 Winner
Dan Jarman’s pair of beefy sandwich shops don’t claim to specialize in brisket, and yet the slices of fat-laced muscle meat that emerge from their smokers in the perfect ratio of meat to grease to burnished edge achieve something few legit houses of barbecue can muster. The word “wings” appears nowhere in its name, but you won’t find smoked appendages more tender or rosy-fleshed than the ones here. And their sizzled tavern-style patties could headline at any high-end burger joint. The only thing Fat Dan’s doesn’t seem to do better than anyone else is wallow in self-congratulation.
NEW THIS YEAR
By the time you read this, Fat Dan’s might be settled into its third location inside the former Crust Pizzeria in Carmel.
Can’t decide? Wearing stretchy pants? Go for the $15 flight of three scaled-down burgers or sandwiches.
5410 N. College Ave., 317-600-3333; 410 E. Michigan St., 317-600-3008