A natural choice for special occasions and other big nights out, Main Street Carmel’s modern cathedral of decorative brick and three-story windows knows how to indulge diners with the best Read more [...]
Anthony’s Chophouse
Price: $$$$Massive double doors marked with a scripty “A” welcome diners to this swanky heavy hitter along Carmel’s bustling Main Street. The interior has the polished gleam of a brand-new Vegas Read more [...]
CLOSED: CharBlue
Price: $$$$The menu at this metrosexy steakhouse is at its best when chef Ricky Hatfield gets adventurous, like with a row of sea salt–roasted heirloom beets served with clouds of dehydrated Read more [...]
CLOSED: Fleming’s Prime Steakhouse
Price: $$$It may not have the kitschy Australian theme of its parent company (Outback Steakhouse’s Bloomin’ Brands), but devoted locals have been returning to this upscale Fashion Mall–area destination like a Read more [...]
CLOSED: Morton’s The Steakhouse
Price: $$$$Like most outposts of this popular house of red meat, the darkened basement location lends a clubby, secret-society feel. Showmanship plays a big part here, and the more-adorned steaks are Read more [...]
Eddie Merlot’s
Price: $$$$At this chain where you order from menus the size of stone tablets, theatrics get the upper hand in the case of a few items: shrimp cocktail with a dry-ice Read more [...]
Geraldine’s Supper Club & Lounge
Price: $$$$Already famous for the slow-smoked brisket, Chicago dogs, and loaded burgers at his two Fat Dan’s Deli locations, restaurateur Dan Jarman goes upscale at this retro homage to his mother Read more [...]
Harry & Izzy’s
Price: $$$Craig Huse’s casual alternative to big brother St. Elmo holds its own as a clubby hangout worthy of destination-steakhouse status itself. The marbled bone-in ribeye sizzles in its juices, a Read more [...]
Hyde Park Prime Steakhouse
Price: $$$This high-windowed luxury dining spot at the corner of Illinois and Market streets seems more in step with the bustling downtown Indy of yore. Anyone who remembers riding the escalators Read more [...]
Ocean Prime
Price: $$$$While this polished national chain offers several cuts of red meat, it shines brightest with its seafood dishes. Blackened snapper, moist inside spice dredging, gets more flavor from a light Read more [...]