R Bistro

When all those gourmet burger–flippers, artisan pizza–bakers, and locavores on Mass Ave say their prayers at night, they should give a nice shout-out to Regina Mehallick. Chef-owner of the moody little 17-table R Bistro since she opened it in 2001, Mehallick was slow-braising Maple Leaf Farms duck legs and tossing local kale with mustard vinaigrette back when a couple of today’s hot young chefs were still in short pants. You can set your Day-Timer by the weekly rotation of her menus—so even her most popular dishes have an ephemeral quality. We fell in love with an early-winter bowl of bacon-and-beet soup, a chunky puree of sweet earthiness that left us with a serious craving. The same goes for a long-gone cider-glazed quail stuffed with bleu cheese and apples. And (hint, hint) we would welcome the return of sous chef Erin Kem’s sauerkraut soup with a ticker-tape parade down Mass Ave.
STICK WITH THE SCRIPT: The kitchen will not abide any substitutions or replacements for what is printed on the evening’s menu, except for dietary restrictions. Don’t even ask.
PREVIOUS MENTIONS: Best Restaurants 2004–2008, 2010–2011, 2013
888 Massachusetts Ave., 317-423-0312, rbistro.com

See all 25 Best Restaurants here.

This article appeared in the May 2014 issue.