Charred Lights A New Flame On The Northside

Italian-born restaurateur Raffaele D’Eusebio enters the northside steakhouse scene with a slender speakeasy-inspired chops spot.

WHEN RAFFAELE D’EUSEBIO bought the popular northside Italian spot Ristorante Roma with wife Alessia in 2020, it didn’t take long for him to start dreaming of a second concept. Yet while plans for a 21-and-over steakhouse with an emphasis on bourbon and wine came together in 2023, it would be more than three years before the new restaurant could sear its first Certified Angus ribeye. “Just when we had things ready, some major issues with the custom hood and exhaust system forced us to tear out the bar and the ceiling,” says general manager Jonathan Dean. “We basically had to start over with the buildout.” Despite a yearlong setback, D’Eusebio and his team remained undeterred. Early this July, Charred made its debut in a sliver of a 70-seat space at Carmel City Center with all the smoke of your local barbecue joint, the intimacy of a speakeasy, and hopes that the new place could stand out not just in Carmel but in Indy’s upscale, aged beef scene. 

That’s a bit of a tall order in a city saturated with steakhouses. Charred’s diminutive size means there isn’t a lot of room left for decor in the darkly handsome dining room where two colorful abstract paintings frame the spacious marble-top bar up front, and black clamshell booths provide window seating. Meanwhile, a nightly soundtrack of turned-up techno music would not be out of place in a dance club. Despite this, an especially thoughtful cocktail selection conceived by former Anthony’s Chophouse bartender Shaun Slinkard and Ristorante Roma alum Cheyenne Leahy soothes with some of the best bourbon and gin sours around, particularly a late-summer seasonal Rosey’s Sour with delicate Japanese Roku gin, woodsy lavender and rosemary, and a nice hit of lemon. The bar’s signature black walnut Manhattan draws true character from six-year WhistlePig rye and Nocello, making for a drink that’s sweeter, rounder, and tastier than the classic. 

To manage the kitchen, D’Eusebio hired on Carmel native Matt Camp, most recently the executive chef of a golf course in Evansville, who brings his skills with saucing and French techniques to Charred’s offerings. Starters deviate little from the classics, though a bright and citrusy tuna crudo with chili oil, avocado mousse, and wasabi wontons brings some Asian flavors to the mix. Steak tartare is a bit more rough-cut than typical versions, but the Angus filet is especially tender, and dollops of bracing Dijon are welcome. Lobster bisque has a great base of shellfish broth with generous hunks of claw meat and an herbaceous drizzle of “emerald oil,” and a wedge salad made with nearly an entire head of romaine and plenty of blue cheese is big enough for the whole table.

Cuts of Angus beef with a variety of accoutrements (such as bone marrow and a restrained bourbon glaze) range from more modest filet mignon and ribeye cap to a whopping 32-ounce dry-aged porterhouse. All of it gets seared over hickory wood fire, which enhances the beefiness of the steaks and gives an earthy note to your meal. Double-cut Australian lamb chops arrive juicy and well-seared on a bed of smooth though not overly decadent Robuchon potatoes. An almost too generous serving of those same potatoes is paired beautifully with braised short ribs that need no steak knife.

Among seafood options, four jumbo scallops are curiously served with al dente risotto that’s colored and sweetened with red cabbage and enriched with bits of jowl bacon and purple asparagus tips. Perhaps the most unexpected offering is a whole Cornish game hen with a delectable cream sauce perfumed with fennel that you can smell immediately when it hits the table. The hen itself shows care with brining, which makes the meat enviably succulent even though the skin is wan without the promised char. All in all, D’Eusebio’s first foray outside of his more familiar Italian cuisine shows plenty of promise. Some refinements to plating and atmosphere might even make it a destination for diners looking for something beyond the beef. 

61 City Center Dr., Carmel
317-564-4840

Hours
Tues–Thu 4:30–10 p.m.; Fri-Sat 4–11 p.m.

Vibe
Speakeasy chophouse

Tasting Notes
Wood-fired Angus steaks with seasonal, local touches

Neighborhood
Carmel City Center

Must-Order
Fischer Farms certified Angus steaks cooked over hickory; generous, juicy Australian lamb chops with Robuchon potatoes; fall-apart braised short ribs with port wine sauce; rich and flavorful lobster bisque with plentiful claw meat; a celebration-worthy slice of mousse cake; an earthy, smoky sweet black walnut Manhattan

Previous articleTonic Ball Celebrates 25 Years Of Fighting Hunger With Live Music
Terry Kirts
Over nearly two decades as a contributing editor at IM, dining critic, and IU Indianapolis creative writing instructor Terry Kirts has championed Indy’s local culinary scene, fork in hand. From mom-and-pops to farm-to-table bistros to the city’s tastiest immigrant cuisine, there’s hardly a dry-aged steak, taco, or bowl of noodles in Central Indiana that he hasn’t tasted.